One/Third Report: Dueling Report Cards

For Tom Greenhalgh's analysis of the Mets lineup, and explanations for each player's grade, click here.

For contributing writer, David V Matrisciano's statistical analysis of the Mets lineup, click here.

SS - JOSE REYES

Tom Greenhalgh, The (Happy?) Recap - C -

David V Matrisciano II, Contributing Writer - C




2B - LUIS CASTILLO

Tom Greenhalgh, The (Happy?) Recap - C+

David V Matrisciano II, Contributing Writer - C -






LF - JASON BAY

Tom Greenhalgh, The (Happy?) Recap - D

David V Matrisciano II, Contributing Writer - B




1B - IKE DAVIS

Tom Greenhalgh, The (Happy?) Recap - A

David V Matrisciano II, Contributing Writer - C






3B - DAVID WRIGHT

Tom Greenhalgh, The (Happy?) Recap - D

David V Matrisciano II, Contributing Writer - B




CF - ANGEL PAGAN

Tom Greenhalgh, The (Happy?) Recap - A

David V Matrisciano II, Contributing Writer - B+






C - ROD BARAJAS

Tom Greenhalgh, The (Happy?) Recap - A+


David V Matrisciano II, Contributing Writer - A-





RF - JEFF FRANCOEUR

Tom Greenhalgh, The (Happy?) Recap - C-

David V Matrisciano II, Contributing Writer - C +